A Christmas Story, directed by Bob Clark and released in 1983, is often celebrated as one of the most enduring and beloved holiday films of all time. Though its initial theatrical run was modest, the film has risen to iconic status, cherished by generations for its nostalgic portrayal of Christmas through the eyes of a young boy, Ralphie Parker. One of the most respected critics to champion the film was Roger Ebert, whose reviews and reflections helped cement A Christmas Story’s reputation as a classic. This article delves into Ebert’s review, the critical reception of the film, and its lasting legacy.
Initial Reception and Ebert’s Review
When A Christmas Story premiered, it received positive critical responses but had a relatively small box office impact. Roger Ebert initially gave the film three stars out of four, appreciating its warm, slice-of-life storytelling. Later, Ebert revisited the film and elevated his rating to four stars, eventually including it in his “Great Movies” list—a prestigious recognition reserved for films of significant cultural and cinematic impact.
Ebert praised the film’s vivid depiction of childhood and Christmas memories, noting that it brought to life the world of Ralphie with affectionate humor and heartfelt moments. His review particularly highlighted the film’s ability to vividly recall the nuances of family dynamics, childhood anticipation, and holiday traditions.
Highlights of Ebert’s Praise
Authentic Childhood Voice and Experiences
Ebert commended A Christmas Story for its authentic portrayal of childhood perspectives. He noted that Ralphie’s narration, voiced by writer Jean Shepherd, combined the innocence of a child with the reflective voice of adulthood, creating a layered and nostalgic storytelling style.
The film’s episodic structure, consisting of memorable vignettes—like Ralphie’s famous visit to Santa Claus and Flick’s frozen tongue dare—effectively captured the mix of humor, frustration, excitement, and wonder that defines childhood.
Memorable Scenes and Characters
Ebert singled out several scenes as classics, including “the Old Man” winning the leg lamp, the department store Santa encounter, and Ralphie’s ongoing battle to convince adults to let him have the Red Ryder BB gun—the “You’ll shoot your eye out!” catchphrase becoming symbolic of childhood hopes dashed by parental concern.
The film’s supporting cast, from Ralphie’s protective family to neighborhood bullies like Scut Farkus, added depth and relatability. Ebert emphasized how these characters collectively contributed to a brilliant ensemble that felt both familiar and unique.
Humor and Sentiment
Roger Ebert lauded the film for balancing humor and sentimentality without becoming saccharine. The comedy arises naturally from family foibles and childhood misadventures rather than forced jokes. Simultaneously, quiet moments—such as family dinners and Ralphie’s reflections on Christmas magic—brought emotional weight and warmth.
Broader Critical Acclaim
Beyond Ebert, A Christmas Story has garnered wide critical acclaim. According to Rotten Tomatoes, the film holds an 89% approval rating, with critics praising its nostalgic charm and universal appeal. Leonard Maltin called it “a top screen comedy,” highlighting the film’s appeal to both kids and adults.
Critics often note the film’s timelessness, remarking on its ability to evoke a specific era while still feeling universally relevant and emotionally resonant.
Lasting Legacy and Cultural Impact
A Christmas Story has transcended its medium to become a cultural institution. Its annual television marathons, especially the 24-hour broadcast on TNT and TBS each Christmas Eve and Christmas Day since the late 1990s, have introduced the movie to new generations and made it a staple of holiday traditions.
The film’s rare blend of humor, nostalgia, and authenticity has influenced numerous filmmakers and holiday films. Its iconic props—like the leg lamp—and memorable quotes have become embedded in popular culture.
In 2012, the United States Library of Congress deemed A Christmas Story culturally and historically significant, selecting it for preservation in the National Film Registry—a testament to its importance in American film history.
Read More: The Impact of A Christmas Story (1983) on Holiday Pop Culture
Conclusion
Roger Ebert’s early and enthusiastic support of A Christmas Story helped cement its status as a beloved holiday classic. His praise for its authentic storytelling, endearing characters, and blend of humor and warmth continues to echo in the film’s enduring popularity today.
For more about Ebert’s review and the film’s rich legacy, visit his official page: A Christmas Story Movie Review – Roger Ebert.
